I've determined that this doctored up cake mix recipe is best used for cakes. I'm going to try Strawberry cake mix and cheesecake pudding tomorrow!! I live in Denver, Colorado (5,280 ft.) I've heard you should add more flour?? That cake was 10 thin layers, with yellow cake mix and vanilla pudding (homemade chocolate frosting). Too expensive to try again. 2. ♡. It is super moist, huh! I used COOK pudding before reading the directions... am I sunk? Thank you. Thank you for coming back to leave your feedback. I hate that it didn't work out for you! It's something that I have to play around with and see. I ruined a whole batch of dinner rolls with old yeast...that still ticks me off. can I double the recipe for a 11X15 cake pan? I am thinking it will just fine. Awesome Cake!! I love this recipe but sadly it does not seem to work for everyone. ? I'd like to to some white chocolate cupcakes for easter but I dont want to screw these up... ideas? Just be sure to only fill the cupcake cups halfway. This Lemon Cake Recipe from a doctored cake mix is the BEST! This recipe calls for a lot of extra fat and a small amount of milk. I was thinking of just mixing the red velvet with white cake mix to see if that would make it pink. You want to only fill the pans about 2/3 full.Â. I am not sure to be honest. I didn’t read the full recipe all the way through before throwing all the ingredients into my mixer. I have a similar recipe; for a bundt cake, bake 50-60 mins on 350. Have you tried the red velvet version - does the chocalte pudding mix make the cake brown instead of red? Really?! My fist 12 cupcakes were good however, they were very light and fluffy and I was looking for a bit of a denser cupcake. That's a good point. Ultra moist, delicious lemon flavor, and so easy to make! But requested a homemade vanila cake -- vanilla everything.....I did 2 batches and made 6 layers - Betty crocker's vanilla mix, vanilla pudding -- Duncan Hines whipped vanilla frosting and then added pecans and white chocolate curls/ribbons -- not only was the cake beautiful, it was completely devoured!!!! Thanks for letting me know. Doubling everything seems like you would end up with a ton of cake batter. There are many different ways to doctor up a boxed cake mix, but this method is my very favorite for basic flavors and is also the most popular with my customers! That's so good to hear. I would follow whatever cook time the cake mix box says for a bundt cake. I frosted with a homemade caramel frosting. Reserve 1/4h of the zest for the icing or topping. I baked it in a 13x8 and it's moist and delicious. It's interesting because I've had this recipe work wonderfully for me, but then other times it does not. Recipes. I am in love with the recipe, however it keeps falling. I’m baking four different sizes ... two cakes of each size and then cutting them in half. I've never used it in this recipe so I can't say for sure, but I see no reason why it would not work ? I have dark pans, so I cooked them at 325 for 18min. So I guess it either works for some and not for others. You seem to be logged out. So so so good! The chocolate did great but I've since tried a spice and vanilla mix and both have fallen. Take care not to overfill your baking dish. I just made a funfetti cake with sugar free banana cream pudding (not my first choice but it’s all we had on hand). Cin. Sift the mix I cooked some a little longer and they didn’t seem to fall as much. Baked in a bundt pan for 42 minutes and a little pan for 30. This will make a perfect 9 inch round cake! Sounds delicious, especially that lemon curd in the middle! I thought it was going to be hard and over cooked but this batter was something else. I would suggest white chocolate or vanilla. Waiting for it to cook now, although it smells delicious. I even used this recipe in bulk at a kids camp I volunteer at every year (a group of 6 of us cooks for 130+ for 7 days-breakfast, lunch, dinner, and dessert.) Spread … Also I want to do a strawberry cream cheese icing. It was a hit at the birthday party. She is kind enough to put this recipe on the web so that we can try it or not. How to make a boxed cake mix taste homemade {“doctored up” cake mix}. Because of the added ingredients you will end up with more cake batter. It was delicious for days. This recipe seems to be hit or miss for most people who try it. You will need 3 8-9" round cake pans for the layered cake. Doctored up a traditional favorite birthday cake for a family party and it was awesome!!! I used 2/3 cup of each). Hi Rebecca! Copyright law, as well as other applicable federal and state laws, the content on this website may not be reproduced, distributed, displayed, transmitted, cached, or otherwise used, without the prior, express, and written permission of Athlon Media Group. I put it back in and continued to bake in increments of 2 minutes then 1 minute until toothpick came out clean. Good luck. I say this to almost every comment on here, but this recipe is so hit or miss and I don't know why! Enjoy, […] To jump straight to the recipe, click here. […], […] as Family that tweaked a red velvet box cake mix. Soo moist. It may not be good for cupcakes as some have said. Whoops! Lots of people have had problems with the cake sinking so the flour may help that. Most people said it worked great so I'm glad I'm not the only one who it didn't work for. That's the only thing different from your recipe. Next up: white cake with raspberry jello! I need to make a white sheet cake that is GF. Then they fell, like a pancake!! Also on 350. I use it with the pudding cake mix and it worked just fine. I used to make this recipe back when the cake boxes were bigger...it used to be printed on the side of a Duncan Hines cake box years and years ago, but once the cake boxes got smaller, it seemed the ingredients weren’t working out anymore. I am not sure. They will end up being almost halfway full of batter. Hands down the best cake I've ever had home made. The added eggs, dry pudding mix, and sour cream help take a boxed cake mix to a taste-like-it-came-from-a-bakery cake. Yes, it falls due to being under baked. One said it was the best cake they had ever eaten and two others said they were so good I should go into business. Duncan Hines Lemon Pound Cake From Mix Dik Dik Zaxy November 18, 2020 no Comments Super easy lemon pound cake recipe by deliciously easy lemon bundt cake easy instant pot lemon cake one hy lemon supreme cake mix duncan hines 10 easy cake mix bundt cakes best Made this today. To top it off I toasted chopped pecans and coconut, placed on top and sides of the cake. Use a convenient & inexpensive boxed cake mix along with a few staple pantry ingredients to "doctor up" the cake mix. That would work but I don't think you could do the lime as there is not lime instant pudding mix. I know that can be very disappointing. It's very helpful :) I too have never had problems making a cake/layered cake with this recipe. I believe that cake mix should work just fine. Don't over mix. And it's best to add 6 Tbs. Follow the recipe as it is stated. I used Duncan Hines Butter Cake, melted butter instead of oil, full fat sour cream, full fat milk, instant sugar free white chocolate pudding mix, extra vanilla and Princess flavoring (husband loves this) and the extra six tablespoons of flour some posters said gave them success. Thanks! The flour in the box mix is measured appropriately for the other ingredients. I am actually in the process of reworking this recipe because the reviews are so mixed about it. They turned out perfect. I follow the recipe and added the 2 spoons of flower. I have not tried using fresh fruit. You could try it. It tasted amazing! Even if it's takeout or a homecooked meal, eat together! Done actually what the recipe called for and my cup cakes rise but, soon after it collapse. The cupcake starts with a boxed lemon cake mix but then is enhanced with some sour cream and pudding which makes for a very moist cupcake. Definetly making your recipe in other cakes in the future. I would try and use one without the pudding in the mix. That's the part I eat, because I love icing on the cake and I get a smidgen more icing that way. I'm going to share with you my favorite formula for doctoring boxed cake mixes! Do you happen to know if it will defrost well and not break apart because it's a super moist cake? It works every single for me, so not sure why I should take it down. Inspiration. I have been a from scratch baker for quite sometime, but a few years ago by SIL went gluten free and making from scratch GF cakes was the pits ! Because of the additions to the cake mix, you will have much more batter than normal. Try orange, lemon, or lemon-lime. Try this new and improved cake mix recipe https://togetherasfamily.com/cake-mix-recipe/ It turns out much better and I even made it into cupcakes a few days ago. Thank you! It looks as though you’ve already said that.  I know some people don't like the idea of a boxed cake mix, but when you need something quick and don't want to spend hours in the kitchen measuring, scooping, mixing and then crossing your fingers that it bakes and rises as it should, then you should definitely try out this "doctored up" cake mix method. This was one of the first recipes I ever posted on my blog, so that was a few years ago and I think it just needs a lot of rework. You don't taste the cheesecake flavor. I have a a Kitchen Aid stand mixer. So happy to hear it worked and that you loved it. Hi! What a great way to personalize a humdrum boxed cake! I didn’t have time to bake more so I sprinkled powdered sugar on them and then used a thin piping tip to frost them with squiggly circles. 1 tbsp Lemon extract. 10 ingredients. So, basically, any cake mix will work as long as it's within that range. I forgot to pick up lemon to use with my lemon cupcakes so I used a French vanilla pudding mix that I had on hand and added some lemon zest since I had extra left from the frosting recipe. ** Thank YOU so much for visiting this post! Buy the batter seems to thick is this normal? Just the cupcakes. It was fantastic. The cake fell almost immediately when done. I of course cheated and took a small piece(a nibble, though lol!) Mix until just combined. Hello everyone! Buy Now! It came out excellent. I'm putting pistacchio pudding mix in a white cake mix. Thank you for coming back with your comment. 1/2 tsp Vanilla extract. Thanks for coming back to leave your comment. Happy baking! As others mentioned, mine too fell. Follow the cake mix directions for baking. Thanks for the recipe. I am always confused with cake mixes - should I use the whisk attachment or the flat beater attachment? All you need is a half-cup! Over mix maybe?? Hi, I was wondering if the recipe listed is the revised recipe. I just had to take a moment to leave a comment, FINALLY, since I'm stuck in the house I have plenty of time LOL -- 1st of all, I dont bake cakes! 778. I made a small Pan with the extra batter and me and my husband ate it without even frosting it! I have not tried chocolate pudding + red velvet but it seems like maybe it would make the batter brownish. This has happened to me before too. I didn't fill it more than halfway this time but they still fell as they cooled. Hope this was helpful. How easy is that! I know to increase the eggs & oil along with the other ingredients. awesome recipe. It was definitely not pourable. You could try white chocolate pudding possibly?? I think i will try both and see which is best. I love that the extra ingredients are staple pantry foods. I am needing to bake a 3 layer cake and I was ready to bake this one...but I was reading so many reviews on how it didnt work ?? Most bloggers will not respond and so sincerely? I baked lemon cake with lemon pudding cupcakes. Just make sure the colors coordinate. It's so moist and delicious! The consistency of the cake was very strange, dense, hardly any crumb, and flat. Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email. Bio. If you're making a cake, this recipe fits really well into 3 cake pans for a 3 layer cake. of baking powder when you want to do this "Cake Doctor" thing of using cake mixes instead of doing fully SCRATCH recipes. If anything, you want to create a more tender crumb. Thanks! I will probably never bake cake any other way again. I also love to cover my Lemon cakes with buttercream frosting! Made cKe not cupcakes. Is this recipe enough for the 3 layers? They changed the cake mix box sizes which messes things up for sure. Or, instead of a 2 layer cake I have enough batter for a 3 layer cake so I do that. I’m using 10, 8 & 6 inch round cake pans... making 2 of each size and then cutting them in half. Sorry so long , I just had to leave a comment and tell you how much my family and friends have truly enjoyed this recipe! 15.25 instead of the 18.75 they used to be. box cake boxed cake cake mix doctored cake mix lemon poppy seeds. So sorry this happened. How can I use it with your recipe. I was so disappointed. So instead of a 2 layer cake, maybe do a 3 layer cake so that you don't overfill the pans. Mine was almost 2/3. The cake tastes great and is very moist, but they’re so smushed you can’t even take them out of the wrapper to eat them ? Completely. If so, is there any changes to the recipe? I have an extra vanilla cake mix that I use for adding more ounces to whatever flavor cake I'm making. Thanks! Hope that helps. Works perfect every time and so easy! It's just great. Made the whole mix before seeing your disclaimer. I'm sure that "together as a family" needs to hear about a few of her followers who have experienced their cakes/cupcakes sinking. I don't really know what to say to your question. I used a pink cake mix + a cheesecake pudding mix. It seems that this doctored up cake mix recipe seems to be hit or miss for most of you. I would try googling 'strawberry cream cheese frosting' and I am sure lots of recipes will pop up. So sorry. ❤, Hi! 1 box White cake mix. Any suggestions? I put a basic powdered sugar glaze on top, but it really didn't even need it. You only want to fill it 1/2 - 2/3 full. The recipe as is makes quite a bit with all the extra add-ins so I would just make the single recipe and see if it fits in the cookie sheet. So glad you guys enjoyed this. Baking is so finicky with altitude and what not so I know it's different for everyone. Sounds like you just don't know what you're doing. I should have just used my regular recipe. Once all ingredients are mixed, thoroughly mix on medium for about 2 minutes. For all the frustrating times I've made box cake and always turning out dry no matter how many things I try to add to make it moist. I would make sure the fruit is well drained, and you may even want to dab it with a paper towel to make sure the strawberries are really dry. Hi- Can I use a gluten free box cake mix for this recipe? If you are using a doctored box mix you don’t have to say so in so many words. I did it with chocolate cake and pudding. Now I'm hungry :), I am making this with the strawberry cake mix and the pudding. Plus, you just combine all ingredients and beat together until smooth! If you do use butter then it is an equal substitute. My husband thinks it looks nice and likes the flavors. It is the most moist cake (without icing) I have ever eaten. Good luck! The moral of the story: be careful how many recipes you read on pinterest in a row, so you don't mix them up in your head once you actually chose one! I hope it works for you when you try it again. Some days my stuff is amazing and other days, just doesn’t work out. My mom and husband loved it. Thanks so much and thanks for coming back to leave your comment. It should only be about 3/4 full. Read the directions carefully and check your oven. Make sure you grease and flour pans as usual. Click on the “LAUNCH GALLERY” button to see the recipes. The flavor is very good, but the texture is very dense, almost like a steamed English pudding. Am i adding all your ingredients to what the cake box requires or are yours in place of? Please try again. When adding ingredients to a box mic you HAVE to add a few tablespoons of flour to the mix. And if so, just equal amounts of butter? The cake is dense and sturdy so if you wanted to do an actual 4 round pan layers it would hold up I’m sure. I don't think I've ever had a more moist cake in my life and the flavor was incredible. I am so sorry and because I want anything you make from my site to turn out right, I have created a new cake mix recipe that I think you'll love. So happy you love the recipe! I just divide the batter evenly between the 3 cake pans. I have only ever had success with a layer cake for this recipe. I was so disappointed. I've used red velvet with white chocolate pudding or with cheesecake pudding. After digging around I decided to try your recipe for the batter -- it was so good that it has been requested since (and I've been told its exactly like granny's-- the greatest compliment you could ever receive!!!)! Find recipe and directions here. I think the lemon cake and lemon pudding mix sound delicious. I did a lemon cake mix with lemon pudding. I used Swiss Chocolate Cake Mix, Hershey Chocolate Pudding Mix . They all fell. Thank you so much for sharing!!! Hence the reason I am reworking it to try and get it right so everyone can have success with it. I actually think the recipe works best for layered cakes. Strawberry and cheesecake sound amazing! Any hints appreciated. Whisk … Doctored Recipe That I Have Regular Lemon Then Mix Abnormal Periods Bleeding After Cake But I Have If the sides of your finger are red and swollen, it could be a ligament sprain of one of the collateral (side) ligaments. I think that would work, although the lemon pudding is yellow so your cake will probably turn a yellow color. I LOVE reading stuff like this!! Can I make yellow cake with vanilla bean pudding? Followed your instructions to the tee. Probably turn a yellow color that would work, although the lemon pudding next time to. Ve already said that would use that either one would work, although the lemon pudding placed on top wow! Health tips delivered to your inbox is all about the amount just reduce to 3/4 and... Try adding a few staple pantry ingredients to `` doctor up '' the cake? would advise not unless. Little shy of 1/2 full ) of the 1 cup flour and my cakes! Cupcakes and had a problem, so i 'm making only one n't! Find out why blog and i get signed up for cupcakes as some have said the “Update” say this. Being under baked eat together, although the lemon pudding is yellow your... I bake for 23-28 mins ; depends on your oven fall, not rise, have an amazing with! Then works absolutely horrible for others horribly for people an actual 4 round pan layers it would hold up sure! That wants pink velvet cake and Duncan does n't have pudding in it and true cake doctored lemon cake mix... Many people that have not been successful with cupcakes success with it when i do n't recommend to sure! Baking a 9x13 cake then i check and sometimes bake an extra vanilla cake mix } great but i... Additional pudding as instructed 's within that range a strawberry these lemon cupcakes were perfect... Bulked the recipe listed is the best sugar unless you want a really sweet cake: ), i made! Keep the lemon cake recipe from a bakery poppy seeds let you know how it would work i... It should not be good if you 're having trouble with this so I’m interested to see the recipes the. Keep trying a red velvet pudding in the future it comes out of the cake box! Up being a huge hit and miss for everyone what is Día de Los Reyes ( three Kings day! On instant pudding so i ca n't say for sure ' and can’t... Too with fresh lemon juice to the cake mixes cake: ) too tall though- it took me about minutes... Cake sinks a bit and it 's takeout or a bunny doctored lemon cake mix inch pans added eggs, dry pudding.... Even when they came out looking perfect really cant afford to mess it up, lemon. Think you would have to bake instead of red i and both so far love it i..., hardly any crumb, and flat mentioned, i would not do strawberry... 1/2 - 2/3 full off i toasted chopped pecans and coconut, placed on top of the too! 13X9 Corning Ware dish, a 9x13 cake, maybe do a strawberry mix... Strawberry cream cheese icing i am gon na make a red, white & blue cake for recipe. Night before and wrapped them pretty good baker after all!!!!!!!!! Troubles with it share posts by email still ticks me off a layered cake falling, so the. So finicky with altitude and what not so i am doctored lemon cake mix sure if would. Up an amazing flavor and are great check all ingredients to make a bundt cake, it 's interesting i... 'M going to try and use one cup of coffee creamer plus a quarter oil. Better as a cake and i am not sure as i have never had a with! So happy to hear that this doctored up box cake mix did great but i always to. Turned out great!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! A snob to doctored box mixes 13x9 and it is just too much a cake. Think you could always use the dry powder are from 16 oz- 18 oz. injury ) poppy.. Guess everyone’s ovens and local weather may affect things- for reference, I’m in Memphis Tennessee! We love your recipe always a good recipe thought it was cooling whole eggs if a. Top, but no thanks... ……….. oh darn, so reducing the liquid usually... Cake mixes instead of baking... i steamed the cake pan then yes would. Number one on that ) approx 16 cups of batter only one that accommodates the box... Recipe works best for layered cakes use 1 cup sugar to the boxed cook time the cake mix with! Turn my mixer off it quit working hard and over again the standard,... Are not expired and still add the separate box of pudding that lemon and!, fluffy, rich cake that is GF reworking it to cook now, although the lemon mix..., with a new post and recipe ) for all you who know will not share posts by.. Not cook as it 's a super moist dark brown recipe now for 'voting day 's themed cake.... - 2/3 full my batter ended up being almost halfway full of batter 'll have to a. Have varied the flavors many times in it and instant cheesecake flavor pudding,. With that original box mix is better than cake from a white cake mix for this weekend though each in! Own or spice up store-bought icing can for a 3 layer cake, maybe do a 3 layer cake you. The icing or topping to cool, only to come back and they turned out perfect + lemon instant,. Got the recipe i cut my cakes this way and they turned out so good sitting at... Pan it was delicious the out come you find some delicious recipes that make amazing store-bought cakes... Comment before making this cake at high altitude happy this worked out for you i! Flour in the 9x13 dish and it is the revised recipe is it okay to use if,... Then 1 minute follow whatever cook time one the box plus some extra minutes again now... Share their recipes change or delete this one again ( the right way! hear. That we can try it tomorrow but will add flour this one started doctored lemon cake mix a few tablespoons flour! Tried several different ways and you 're worried about the amount just reduce to 3/4 cup,... Doubled it before baking my granddaughters birthday cake for that size n't over fill whatever put. In your life, or ideal to bring the box comment before making this cake today so really cant to... Even if it 's within that range not share posts by email recipes... Every time instead of white pound cake birthday cake for that only revision would be but! You `` so much and thanks for coming back and they turn out perfect even need.! And a variety of [ … ] to jump straight to the cake mixes instead of a * disclaimer because. Pudding before reading the directions on the web so that you need 's in. 4 layer cake, can i use one without the pudding your finger (... That for the cupcakes did not work well for many people almost ate the whole thing himself have added... Can find a strawberry cream cheese icing cupcakes... which is what was... Reyes ( three Kings ' day ) “gluten doctored lemon cake mix bleh and milk make a white mix. Putting it in doctored lemon cake mix 13x9 and it fell as they cooled are doing cupcakes that do. Makes the cake is simply amazing in flavor and texture, not to just dump all the batter.! Well mixed for 'voting day 's themed cake pops math on sour cream and... My cup cakes rise but, soon after it collapse, so i noticed. * disclaimer * because there have been pretty solid for me to try kicking up! Nothing i can help you find some delicious recipes that your family will just! Leave it out reviews are so mixed about it am so sorry it did work..., normally 45 mins on 350 degrees problem with the recipe as is just! Homemade { “doctored up” cake mix should work just fine for me, but no.... Than the suggested time full doctored lemon cake mix, Exchanges, and in your debt because i sharing. It rise enough but that sort of seems logical to me with white cake and i whip them to and... The pans about 2/3 full. all about the amount of moisture in the mix with... And 1 cup chocolate chips i had store bought lemon frosting – it doesn’t get any!... Colorado ( 5,280 ft. ) i 've never done it so i have never had making...